{
  "canonicalCommit": "88bcbfcc8b17af30837313aff596cec8e1bde43a",
  "scope": "Three authored reviews of the expanded written sourcebook and original scalar files. Later instrument and laboratory packets are not inputs to these reviews. Earlier short-example claims remain in their original history.",
  "documents": {
    "entities": {
      "documentId": "meridian-assessment-input-entities-v1",
      "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:research-entities:0.2.0",
      "sha256": "fa88c7cfdc2577e97f2b75e06417e3121acdffabe34db0de47aa7d35f1da0fec"
    },
    "history": {
      "documentId": "meridian-expanded-review-history-v1",
      "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:claim-history:0.4.0",
      "sha256": "8bb89116d559b61e1837311da987b75cf5cd86a472ca34a5c9173c316a16ec05"
    }
  },
  "retainedSnapshots": {
    "reader": {
      "observation.json": "31a1e4b3ce0a56195f7e1004e182793f6575fe613d086aa9de98d89160b1dde4",
      "entities.json": "5d5252540e12b682723f3a7045482a7858f1aa8b242b673d7ac7a7122ce93151",
      "index.json": "ccf009b8fed08db4e48f332bd08c274375fc4a7e7928c20c3dd0d86b5a9fbd9a",
      "sources/reviews.md": "24a285742351a0063cbbf1c03d64f8bfc911c6abe4524c0b2d00c7499fefe622",
      "sources/report-a.md": "461eb15b81e16b4950b6a8b06b5852db10cc753a66794d42e2c13804c013ff04",
      "sources/report-b.md": "be42555e86eb0f4419ade177687960448adb6aa5523117e61580230d21ce7eb1",
      "sources/account-a.md": "19fdf581a00c9a634a042f7d52ef6784c240e0d6146f7ab420505be34cb80d48",
      "sources/account-b.md": "5d30dbfd7c869e02a4107d946ede44b81478f44a0fd2ae01d8c65868c73d4cef",
      "sources/account-a-follow-up.md": "a511d08bac441b967868257170c1c9df383894d94457d8015cef98420ee7c889",
      "sources/site-plan.svg": "fd4b5b5cab3b8d84e6cfebd72d02bce59bef2194b320d7b87c2ab8f054210b5b",
      "sources/asset-specifications.json": "6143000e440d25e5c986ce771aebdd64b10e39f6d8498b4baeab64cde92dc09c"
    },
    "original": {
      "optical.csv": "08ae25c833684504eb82942df5b7367dbfacc6be31d71ae1cc584e6fffeb4175",
      "radio.csv": "fe18aff93123886c6c1b6f1117f76daf8ab074aa30e93c1bccbe1988b8e854ee",
      "temperature.csv": "4a9c6622088b89d469d190b2a3dc4169af6f8d3a39374b08ef143bfeff370478",
      "fixture.mjs": "e641ab9ccca73c66eff50b858b59c60f1801f8a351a17f32865f4d829cc2d7aa",
      "history.json": "14c21d2a24d56ecde861864d4400a913ff2aff2fd29960102a136854f94f32ef"
    }
  },
  "reviews": [
    {
      "id": "initial",
      "title": "A shared source?",
      "question": "Do the accounts and scalar recordings establish one physical source?",
      "summary": "The overlap makes a comparison worth pursuing. It does not establish a common object.",
      "topic": "shared_source_hypothesis",
      "recordedAt": "2026-08-15T12:00:00Z",
      "evaluatedBy": "Meridian review team (fictional)",
      "inputs": [
        "report-a",
        "account-a",
        "account-b",
        "optical",
        "radio",
        "temperature",
        "generator"
      ],
      "limits": "No independent exact account timing, range, or emitter identity. Similar curves were generated together.",
      "followUp": "Obtain source-resolved imagery and radio information, describe camera geometry and characterize timing for the intended comparison.",
      "claim": {
        "id": "initial",
        "kind": "assessment",
        "recordedAt": "2026-08-15T12:00:00Z",
        "topic": "shared_source_hypothesis",
        "subject": {
          "kind": "observation"
        },
        "status": "assessed",
        "outcome": "inconclusive",
        "evaluatedBy": "Meridian review team (fictional)",
        "evaluatedAt": "2026-08-15T12:00:00Z",
        "methodRef": "method:source-comparison",
        "methodVersion": "1",
        "inputRefs": [
          "source:review-method.md",
          "source:review-catalog.json",
          "claim:note-initial",
          "source:r2-report-a",
          "source:r2-account-a",
          "source:r2-account-b",
          "source:review-original-optical",
          "source:review-original-radio",
          "source:review-original-temperature",
          "source:review-original-generator"
        ],
        "editionInputRefs": [
          {
            "document": {
              "documentId": "meridian-assessment-input-entities-v1",
              "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:research-entities:0.2.0",
              "sha256": "fa88c7cfdc2577e97f2b75e06417e3121acdffabe34db0de47aa7d35f1da0fec"
            },
            "editionId": "a",
            "artifact": {
              "sourceRef": "source:r2-report-a",
              "digest": {
                "algorithm": "sha256",
                "value": "461eb15b81e16b4950b6a8b06b5852db10cc753a66794d42e2c13804c013ff04"
              }
            },
            "locator": {
              "kind": "page",
              "page": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "document": {
              "documentId": "meridian-assessment-input-entities-v1",
              "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:research-entities:0.2.0",
              "sha256": "fa88c7cfdc2577e97f2b75e06417e3121acdffabe34db0de47aa7d35f1da0fec"
            },
            "editionId": "account-a",
            "artifact": {
              "sourceRef": "source:r2-account-a",
              "digest": {
                "algorithm": "sha256",
                "value": "19fdf581a00c9a634a042f7d52ef6784c240e0d6146f7ab420505be34cb80d48"
              }
            },
            "locator": {
              "kind": "page",
              "page": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "document": {
              "documentId": "meridian-assessment-input-entities-v1",
              "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:research-entities:0.2.0",
              "sha256": "fa88c7cfdc2577e97f2b75e06417e3121acdffabe34db0de47aa7d35f1da0fec"
            },
            "editionId": "account-b",
            "artifact": {
              "sourceRef": "source:r2-account-b",
              "digest": {
                "algorithm": "sha256",
                "value": "5d30dbfd7c869e02a4107d946ede44b81478f44a0fd2ae01d8c65868c73d4cef"
              }
            },
            "locator": {
              "kind": "page",
              "page": 1
            }
          }
        ],
        "rationale": "The selected interval makes a comparison reasonable. The two observers place their descriptions within the short field session, and the generated optical and radio curves have a prominent interval. However, the accounts lack independent exact timing and range. The temperature is a station measurement. The curve similarity is partly built into the simulation. These inputs therefore motivate a question rather than answering it.\n\nThe initial outcome is inconclusive. The proposed next work is to obtain source-resolved imagery and radio information, declare the camera geometry, characterize timing for the intended comparison, and preserve the independent wording of both accounts. The review does not identify an origin or assign a confidence score."
      },
      "note": {
        "file": "inputs/reviews.md",
        "sha256": "24a285742351a0063cbbf1c03d64f8bfc911c6abe4524c0b2d00c7499fefe622",
        "line": 5,
        "text": "<a id=\"initial\"></a>\n## Initial review · Meridian review team · 15 August\n\nInput: edition A, page 2; Observer A's first account; Observer B's first account; the three scalar recordings. Question: do the supplied descriptions and measurements establish a shared physical source?\n\nThe selected interval makes a comparison reasonable. The two observers place their descriptions within the short field session, and the generated optical and radio curves have a prominent interval. However, the accounts lack independent exact timing and range. The temperature is a station measurement. The curve similarity is partly built into the simulation. These inputs therefore motivate a question rather than answering it.\n\nThe initial outcome is inconclusive. The proposed next work is to obtain source-resolved imagery and radio information, declare the camera geometry, characterize timing for the intended comparison, and preserve the independent wording of both accounts. The review does not identify an origin or assign a confidence score."
      },
      "paragraphs": [
        "The selected interval makes a comparison reasonable. The two observers place their descriptions within the short field session, and the generated optical and radio curves have a prominent interval. However, the accounts lack independent exact timing and range. The temperature is a station measurement. The curve similarity is partly built into the simulation. These inputs therefore motivate a question rather than answering it.",
        "The initial outcome is inconclusive. The proposed next work is to obtain source-resolved imagery and radio information, declare the camera geometry, characterize timing for the intended comparison, and preserve the independent wording of both accounts. The review does not identify an origin or assign a confidence score."
      ],
      "current": false
    },
    {
      "id": "revised",
      "title": "A narrower conclusion",
      "question": "What changes when the follow-up and revised report are included?",
      "summary": "A shared physical source remains unestablished. Separate sources have not been proven either.",
      "topic": "shared_source_hypothesis",
      "recordedAt": "2026-08-16T12:00:00Z",
      "evaluatedBy": "Meridian review team (fictional)",
      "inputs": [
        "report-b",
        "follow-up",
        "inventory",
        "account-a",
        "account-b",
        "optical",
        "radio",
        "temperature",
        "generator"
      ],
      "limits": "More documents do not supply independent measurements. The follow-up was written after the observer saw the graphs.",
      "followUp": "Compare actual native products with stated clock and geometry assumptions, background periods and a test of association defined in advance.",
      "supersedes": [
        "claim:initial"
      ],
      "claim": {
        "id": "revised",
        "kind": "assessment",
        "recordedAt": "2026-08-16T12:00:00Z",
        "topic": "shared_source_hypothesis",
        "subject": {
          "kind": "observation"
        },
        "status": "assessed",
        "outcome": "inconclusive",
        "evaluatedBy": "Meridian review team (fictional)",
        "evaluatedAt": "2026-08-16T12:00:00Z",
        "methodRef": "method:source-comparison",
        "methodVersion": "1",
        "inputRefs": [
          "source:review-method.md",
          "source:review-catalog.json",
          "claim:note-revised",
          "source:r2-report-b",
          "source:r2-account-a-follow-up",
          "source:r2-asset-specifications",
          "source:r2-account-a",
          "source:r2-account-b",
          "source:review-original-optical",
          "source:review-original-radio",
          "source:review-original-temperature",
          "source:review-original-generator"
        ],
        "editionInputRefs": [
          {
            "document": {
              "documentId": "meridian-assessment-input-entities-v1",
              "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:research-entities:0.2.0",
              "sha256": "fa88c7cfdc2577e97f2b75e06417e3121acdffabe34db0de47aa7d35f1da0fec"
            },
            "editionId": "b",
            "artifact": {
              "sourceRef": "source:r2-report-b",
              "digest": {
                "algorithm": "sha256",
                "value": "be42555e86eb0f4419ade177687960448adb6aa5523117e61580230d21ce7eb1"
              }
            },
            "locator": {
              "kind": "page",
              "page": 3
            }
          },
          {
            "document": {
              "documentId": "meridian-assessment-input-entities-v1",
              "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:research-entities:0.2.0",
              "sha256": "fa88c7cfdc2577e97f2b75e06417e3121acdffabe34db0de47aa7d35f1da0fec"
            },
            "editionId": "account-a-follow-up",
            "artifact": {
              "sourceRef": "source:r2-account-a-follow-up",
              "digest": {
                "algorithm": "sha256",
                "value": "a511d08bac441b967868257170c1c9df383894d94457d8015cef98420ee7c889"
              }
            },
            "locator": {
              "kind": "page",
              "page": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "document": {
              "documentId": "meridian-assessment-input-entities-v1",
              "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:research-entities:0.2.0",
              "sha256": "fa88c7cfdc2577e97f2b75e06417e3121acdffabe34db0de47aa7d35f1da0fec"
            },
            "editionId": "account-a",
            "artifact": {
              "sourceRef": "source:r2-account-a",
              "digest": {
                "algorithm": "sha256",
                "value": "19fdf581a00c9a634a042f7d52ef6784c240e0d6146f7ab420505be34cb80d48"
              }
            },
            "locator": {
              "kind": "page",
              "page": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "document": {
              "documentId": "meridian-assessment-input-entities-v1",
              "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:research-entities:0.2.0",
              "sha256": "fa88c7cfdc2577e97f2b75e06417e3121acdffabe34db0de47aa7d35f1da0fec"
            },
            "editionId": "account-b",
            "artifact": {
              "sourceRef": "source:r2-account-b",
              "digest": {
                "algorithm": "sha256",
                "value": "5d30dbfd7c869e02a4107d946ede44b81478f44a0fd2ae01d8c65868c73d4cef"
              }
            },
            "locator": {
              "kind": "page",
              "page": 1
            }
          }
        ],
        "rationale": "The revised wording is “a shared physical source remains unestablished.” This is not a finding that separate sources have been proven. The follow-up clarifies the difference between apparent motion and measured physical motion and makes the observer's exposure to the graphs explicit. The richer asset specifications describe what will be useful to inspect, but unavailable recordings cannot count as new supporting measurements.\n\nThe review retains an inconclusive outcome with a more explicit account of the missing relationship. It does not use the increased number of documents as an increase in scientific confidence. Its proposed follow-up is a defined comparison using actual native products, clock and geometry assumptions, background periods and a stated test of association.",
        "supersedes": [
          "claim:initial"
        ]
      },
      "note": {
        "file": "inputs/reviews.md",
        "sha256": "24a285742351a0063cbbf1c03d64f8bfc911c6abe4524c0b2d00c7499fefe622",
        "line": 14,
        "text": "<a id=\"revised\"></a>\n## Revised review · Meridian review team · 16 August\n\nInput: edition B, page 3; the retained first accounts; Observer A's follow-up; unchanged scalar recordings; source inventory. Earlier assessment retained: initial review, edition A, page 2.\n\nThe revised wording is “a shared physical source remains unestablished.” This is not a finding that separate sources have been proven. The follow-up clarifies the difference between apparent motion and measured physical motion and makes the observer's exposure to the graphs explicit. The richer asset specifications describe what will be useful to inspect, but unavailable recordings cannot count as new supporting measurements.\n\nThe review retains an inconclusive outcome with a more explicit account of the missing relationship. It does not use the increased number of documents as an increase in scientific confidence. Its proposed follow-up is a defined comparison using actual native products, clock and geometry assumptions, background periods and a stated test of association."
      },
      "paragraphs": [
        "The revised wording is “a shared physical source remains unestablished.” This is not a finding that separate sources have been proven. The follow-up clarifies the difference between apparent motion and measured physical motion and makes the observer's exposure to the graphs explicit. The richer asset specifications describe what will be useful to inspect, but unavailable recordings cannot count as new supporting measurements.",
        "The review retains an inconclusive outcome with a more explicit account of the missing relationship. It does not use the increased number of documents as an increase in scientific confidence. Its proposed follow-up is a defined comparison using actual native products, clock and geometry assumptions, background periods and a stated test of association."
      ],
      "current": true
    },
    {
      "id": "alternative",
      "title": "Separate sources?",
      "question": "Could independent sources and viewing conditions account for the apparent association?",
      "summary": "Independent sources remain a possible explanation, without an identification or probability.",
      "topic": "separate_sources_hypothesis",
      "recordedAt": "2026-08-16T12:00:00Z",
      "evaluatedBy": "Meridian comparison reviewer (fictional)",
      "inputs": [
        "report-b",
        "account-a",
        "account-b",
        "site",
        "generator"
      ],
      "limits": "Different descriptions do not resolve measured shape. The radio channel identifies no emitter. No aircraft, psychological cause or origin has been established.",
      "followUp": "Collect pointing, timing and spectral information that could distinguish a common source from independent sources, rather than assuming either explanation.",
      "claim": {
        "id": "alternative",
        "kind": "assessment",
        "recordedAt": "2026-08-16T12:00:00Z",
        "topic": "separate_sources_hypothesis",
        "subject": {
          "kind": "observation"
        },
        "status": "assessed",
        "outcome": "inconclusive",
        "evaluatedBy": "Meridian comparison reviewer (fictional)",
        "evaluatedAt": "2026-08-16T12:00:00Z",
        "methodRef": "method:source-comparison",
        "methodVersion": "1",
        "inputRefs": [
          "source:review-method.md",
          "source:review-catalog.json",
          "claim:note-alternative",
          "source:r2-report-b",
          "source:r2-account-a",
          "source:r2-account-b",
          "source:r2-site-plan",
          "source:review-original-generator"
        ],
        "editionInputRefs": [
          {
            "document": {
              "documentId": "meridian-assessment-input-entities-v1",
              "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:research-entities:0.2.0",
              "sha256": "fa88c7cfdc2577e97f2b75e06417e3121acdffabe34db0de47aa7d35f1da0fec"
            },
            "editionId": "b",
            "artifact": {
              "sourceRef": "source:r2-report-b",
              "digest": {
                "algorithm": "sha256",
                "value": "be42555e86eb0f4419ade177687960448adb6aa5523117e61580230d21ce7eb1"
              }
            },
            "locator": {
              "kind": "page",
              "page": 3
            }
          },
          {
            "document": {
              "documentId": "meridian-assessment-input-entities-v1",
              "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:research-entities:0.2.0",
              "sha256": "fa88c7cfdc2577e97f2b75e06417e3121acdffabe34db0de47aa7d35f1da0fec"
            },
            "editionId": "account-a",
            "artifact": {
              "sourceRef": "source:r2-account-a",
              "digest": {
                "algorithm": "sha256",
                "value": "19fdf581a00c9a634a042f7d52ef6784c240e0d6146f7ab420505be34cb80d48"
              }
            },
            "locator": {
              "kind": "page",
              "page": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "document": {
              "documentId": "meridian-assessment-input-entities-v1",
              "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:research-entities:0.2.0",
              "sha256": "fa88c7cfdc2577e97f2b75e06417e3121acdffabe34db0de47aa7d35f1da0fec"
            },
            "editionId": "account-b",
            "artifact": {
              "sourceRef": "source:r2-account-b",
              "digest": {
                "algorithm": "sha256",
                "value": "5d30dbfd7c869e02a4107d946ede44b81478f44a0fd2ae01d8c65868c73d4cef"
              }
            },
            "locator": {
              "kind": "page",
              "page": 1
            }
          }
        ],
        "rationale": "The observer positions differ and one view is partly obstructed. A bright unresolved patch can lead to different descriptions without establishing a contradiction in a measured shape. The scalar radio channel does not identify an emitter. The known shared generator also limits what can be learned from the curves' resemblance. Independent-source explanations therefore deserve explicit consideration.\n\nThis reviewer does not declare an aircraft identification, a psychological cause or a probability distribution over the origin catalog. Each would require additional information. The alternative remains an attributed hypothesis. A later finding could support, narrow or challenge it while retaining the exact inputs on which it was proposed."
      },
      "note": {
        "file": "inputs/reviews.md",
        "sha256": "24a285742351a0063cbbf1c03d64f8bfc911c6abe4524c0b2d00c7499fefe622",
        "line": 23,
        "text": "<a id=\"alternative\"></a>\n## Alternative review · Meridian comparison reviewer · 16 August\n\nInput: both first accounts, site diagram, source generator description and edition B, page 3. Question: could independent sources and viewing conditions account for the apparent association?\n\nThe observer positions differ and one view is partly obstructed. A bright unresolved patch can lead to different descriptions without establishing a contradiction in a measured shape. The scalar radio channel does not identify an emitter. The known shared generator also limits what can be learned from the curves' resemblance. Independent-source explanations therefore deserve explicit consideration.\n\nThis reviewer does not declare an aircraft identification, a psychological cause or a probability distribution over the origin catalog. Each would require additional information. The alternative remains an attributed hypothesis. A later finding could support, narrow or challenge it while retaining the exact inputs on which it was proposed."
      },
      "paragraphs": [
        "The observer positions differ and one view is partly obstructed. A bright unresolved patch can lead to different descriptions without establishing a contradiction in a measured shape. The scalar radio channel does not identify an emitter. The known shared generator also limits what can be learned from the curves' resemblance. Independent-source explanations therefore deserve explicit consideration.",
        "This reviewer does not declare an aircraft identification, a psychological cause or a probability distribution over the origin catalog. Each would require additional information. The alternative remains an attributed hypothesis. A later finding could support, narrow or challenge it while retaining the exact inputs on which it was proposed."
      ],
      "current": true
    }
  ],
  "inputs": [
    {
      "id": "report-a",
      "title": "Report A · page 2",
      "file": "inputs/report-a.md",
      "base": "reader",
      "editionId": "a",
      "page": 2,
      "note": "The earlier question and its limits.",
      "originalFile": "sources/report-a.md",
      "sourceRef": "source:r2-report-a",
      "sha256": "461eb15b81e16b4950b6a8b06b5852db10cc753a66794d42e2c13804c013ff04",
      "byteLength": 5881,
      "excerpt": "<!-- page:2 -->\n<a id=\"page-2\"></a>\n## Page 2 · Comparison and initial assessment\n\nObserver A describes a compact triangular arrangement of lights and an apparent rise relative to the ridge. A explicitly does not resolve a connecting surface. Observer B describes a soft oval-looking patch and does not resolve separate points. B's view included a foreground obstruction. The descriptions have meaningful differences, and the record retains both instead of replacing them with a single composite shape.\n\nAt the selected timestamp, the three source channels report:\n\n| Channel | Value at 21:01:30 UTC | Declared standard uncertainty | Source row (header included) |\n| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n| Optical elevation | 39.92 ° | ± 0.2 ° | optical.csv / 11 |\n| Radio power | -42.28 dBm | ± 0.5 dBm | radio.csv / 11 |\n| Ambient temperature | 18.32 °C | ± 0.1 °C | temperature.csv / 11 |\n\nThe declared uncertainties belong to the individual channel examples. They are not an uncertainty estimate for a combined event. Temperature is an ambient station reading. Optical elevation is an angle, not an altitude or speed. Radio power is a scalar quantity without a frequency-resolved emitter identification in this control. The shared pulse function used by the synthetic optical and radio generators also means their similar shapes are not independent experimental corroboration.\n\n**Initial assessment.** A shared source is a question worth examining because the reported interval and the generated recording occupy the same short session. It is not established by that overlap. A useful test would require explicit camera pointing, comparable capture times, source-resolved radio information and a method explaining what a positive or negative result would mean. The observer accounts do not supply the missing distance or timing measurements.\n\nThis is the passage cited by the initial review: **edition A, page 2**. Its wording deliberately stops at a provisional question. The report makes no claim of extraordinary acceleration, transmedium travel or an identified origin.",
      "line": 19,
      "citation": {
        "document": {
          "documentId": "meridian-assessment-input-entities-v1",
          "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:research-entities:0.2.0",
          "sha256": "fa88c7cfdc2577e97f2b75e06417e3121acdffabe34db0de47aa7d35f1da0fec"
        },
        "editionId": "a",
        "artifact": {
          "sourceRef": "source:r2-report-a",
          "digest": {
            "algorithm": "sha256",
            "value": "461eb15b81e16b4950b6a8b06b5852db10cc753a66794d42e2c13804c013ff04"
          }
        },
        "locator": {
          "kind": "page",
          "page": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "report-b",
      "title": "Report B · page 3",
      "file": "inputs/report-b.md",
      "base": "reader",
      "editionId": "b",
      "page": 3,
      "note": "The revised wording and alternative explanation.",
      "originalFile": "sources/report-b.md",
      "sourceRef": "source:r2-report-b",
      "sha256": "be42555e86eb0f4419ade177687960448adb6aa5523117e61580230d21ce7eb1",
      "byteLength": 7217,
      "excerpt": "<!-- page:3 -->\n<a id=\"page-3\"></a>\n## Page 3 · Revised interpretation and alternatives\n\n**Revised assessment.** A shared physical source remains unestablished. The accounts have uncertain temporal alignment and different apparent shapes. The optical angle does not determine distance, the original scalar radio recording does not identify an emitter, and the ambient channel describes the station environment. The synthetic curves' common generator is also known. Their resemblance therefore cannot be treated as an independently reproduced physical relationship.\n\nObserver A's clarification makes a narrower account easier to read: an apparent rise relative to a ridge, without a resolved connecting body or a distance estimate. Observer B's soft oval remains an independent description of B's recollection. Neither account is overwritten, and the review does not choose a shape by majority vote or apparent specificity. Similar words or timestamps would not remove the need to examine viewing conditions and source identity.\n\nAn alternative interpretation is that ordinary independent sources and viewing conditions account for the apparent association. That interpretation is not established either. The current material does not justify assigning a numerical probability to one explanation. A discriminating follow-up would compare known pointing directions, independently characterized timing, spectral information and appropriate background periods. It should define beforehand what would count against an association.\n\nThis passage is the revised review's exact citation: **edition B, page 3**. It supersedes the earlier assessment as the current review position while retaining edition A, page 2 as the earlier input. Structural validation of those links establishes that the references resolve; it does not establish the truth of either interpretation. The full [review notes](reviews.md) state their inputs and limits.",
      "line": 35,
      "citation": {
        "document": {
          "documentId": "meridian-assessment-input-entities-v1",
          "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:research-entities:0.2.0",
          "sha256": "fa88c7cfdc2577e97f2b75e06417e3121acdffabe34db0de47aa7d35f1da0fec"
        },
        "editionId": "b",
        "artifact": {
          "sourceRef": "source:r2-report-b",
          "digest": {
            "algorithm": "sha256",
            "value": "be42555e86eb0f4419ade177687960448adb6aa5523117e61580230d21ce7eb1"
          }
        },
        "locator": {
          "kind": "page",
          "page": 3
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "account-a",
      "title": "Observer A · first account",
      "file": "inputs/account-a.md",
      "base": "reader",
      "editionId": "account-a",
      "page": 1,
      "note": "Apparent arrangement and motion, without distance or exact onset.",
      "originalFile": "sources/account-a.md",
      "sourceRef": "source:r2-account-a",
      "sha256": "19fdf581a00c9a634a042f7d52ef6784c240e0d6146f7ab420505be34cb80d48",
      "byteLength": 4590,
      "excerpt": "# Observer A · First written account\n\nFictional first-person source. Recorded 14 August 2026. Public pseudonym: Observer A. The account was not sworn. The speaker's recollections are not instrument measurements.\n\n<a id=\"account\"></a>\n## Account\n\nI was standing a few steps behind the equipment at Station North when I noticed the light. My main task that evening was to help keep the area around the tripod clear and write down interruptions to the session. I was not operating the radio equipment and could not see its display from where I stood. I had helped with two earlier practice sessions, but I would not describe myself as trained in judging aircraft distance or identifying lights at night. I wore my usual glasses throughout the observation.\n\nThe ridge was easy to make out against the sky. I remember three points, or what looked like three points, close together above its left-hand shoulder. My first impression was of a compact triangle. I cannot now say that I saw a solid surface joining those points. There was darkness between them, and it is possible that part of the impression came from trying to make a pattern out of a bright patch. In my sketch I have drawn three circles because that is the arrangement I remember, not because I counted three separate objects.\n\nThe arrangement appeared to move upward relative to the ridge. At one point it seemed higher and clearer; later it was harder to distinguish. I do not have a distance estimate. It did not pass a known pole, building or aircraft whose size I could use as a reference. The change could be drawn as a rising line on paper, but I cannot attach a speed to that line. I also cannot distinguish movement of the lights from a change in which parts of a larger distant scene were visible to me.\n\nI remember the interval as about a minute. I was not watching a clock at the moment it began, and I did not press an event marker. I looked down once toward the equipment and then back at the ridge. For that reason I cannot claim continuous observation from the first instant to the last. The time written on the session log is the recording time supplied by the team. It should not be read as a timestamp that I independently recorded for the first light I noticed.\n\nThe color looked pale, somewhere between white and a weak yellow, rather than strongly red or blue. I did not see an obvious flashing sequence. That does not mean there was no flashing; I was concentrating on the arrangement and may have missed a slow or irregular change. I did not see exhaust, a trail or a beam extending to the ground. I also did not have a view with enough detail to say that such features could not have been present. My drawing leaves those areas blank because I did not record them.\n\nI heard no sound that I could connect to the light. There were ordinary noises around me: movement near the tripod, clothing in the breeze and occasional distant traffic. I did not stop those noises or compare them against an acoustic recording. I would describe the sound as unrecognized, rather than call the event silent. I did not feel a pressure wave, unusual heat or a change in my balance. Those are recollections from where I stood, not claims about every part of the field site.\n\nAfter the light became difficult to see, I told the operator that I had noticed a triangular arrangement. I did not inspect a video or graph before writing this account. Observer B was farther down the site. We spoke briefly after the recording ended, but I did not read B's written description before completing mine. I understand that speaking about an event can influence later recollection. This account records what I can remember now, including where I am uncertain, rather than trying to reconcile my description with another person's.\n\nI did not walk to the ridge or see anything land. I did not collect a sample that evening. The next day's surface mark was not something I saw being made. If a material sample is included with this field session, my account should not be used to establish its origin. The most useful follow-up would be to compare the camera's actual pointing and frame times with the portion of sky I was watching, while keeping the limits of my timing and distance estimates visible.\n\n## Sketch instruction\n\nThe associated drawing should show three pale points above a ridge outline, an approximate upward arrow and the annotation “arrangement recalled; no connecting surface resolved.” It should include no scale, range, physical speed or inferred craft outline. See [illustration specifications](image-briefs.md).\n",
      "line": 1,
      "citation": {
        "document": {
          "documentId": "meridian-assessment-input-entities-v1",
          "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:research-entities:0.2.0",
          "sha256": "fa88c7cfdc2577e97f2b75e06417e3121acdffabe34db0de47aa7d35f1da0fec"
        },
        "editionId": "account-a",
        "artifact": {
          "sourceRef": "source:r2-account-a",
          "digest": {
            "algorithm": "sha256",
            "value": "19fdf581a00c9a634a042f7d52ef6784c240e0d6146f7ab420505be34cb80d48"
          }
        },
        "locator": {
          "kind": "page",
          "page": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "account-b",
      "title": "Observer B · first account",
      "file": "inputs/account-b.md",
      "base": "reader",
      "editionId": "account-b",
      "page": 1,
      "note": "A different viewpoint and an unresolved oval description.",
      "originalFile": "sources/account-b.md",
      "sourceRef": "source:r2-account-b",
      "sha256": "5d30dbfd7c869e02a4107d946ede44b81478f44a0fd2ae01d8c65868c73d4cef",
      "byteLength": 4617,
      "excerpt": "# Observer B · First written account\n\nFictional first-person source. Recorded 14 August 2026. Public pseudonym: Observer B. The account was not sworn. The speaker's recollections are not instrument measurements.\n\n<a id=\"account\"></a>\n## Account\n\nI was beside Station South for most of the recording. I had been asked to note weather conditions and anything that obstructed the station's view. The position was lower along the access path than Station North. A foreground branch and part of the slope interrupted my view in one direction. I could see the ridge through a gap, but my view was not the same as the one from the other tripod. I stayed near the station rather than walking closer to get a better angle.\n\nWhat attracted my attention was a pale oval-looking light. It did not look like a detailed object. The edge was soft, and I could not tell whether I was seeing one patch or several points blurred together. I did not resolve a triangle. I wrote “oval” because that was the overall impression at the time, but I would not use that word as a precise shape measurement. I could not see a body, windows, wings or any feature that would let me confidently identify its structure.\n\nThe light appeared above the ridge and then became less distinct. I remember looking around the foreground branch to keep it in view. I cannot separate movement of my head from every apparent movement of the light. It seemed to rise slightly, but I did not follow a continuous path across a large section of sky. My drawing shows the gap through which I looked and a short arrow beside the light. The arrow expresses the impression of movement; it is not a measured trajectory and has no distance scale.\n\nI do not know how far away it was. There was no nearby object at the same apparent position that I could compare against it. I have seen ordinary aircraft from this site, but I do not have aviation training. The light's appearance alone did not give me a reliable way to distinguish an aircraft, a distant ground light seen at an angle, or another explanation. I also cannot judge its physical size. A bright small source and a dim larger source might have produced similar impressions from where I stood.\n\nI did not record an exact start time. I remember the station recording was already underway when I noticed it. I glanced at the environmental display during the session, but I did not write down a time for that glance. My estimate of the light's duration is only that it occupied part of the short recording interval. It may have been around a minute, but I would not use that estimate to align an individual video frame or radio peak. The instrument timestamps and my recollection need to remain separate.\n\nI did not notice a strong color change or a regular blinking pattern. The patch looked pale against the darker ridge. The sky around it was not completely black, and there was some ordinary light near the equipment. I do not recall heavy cloud, rain or a sudden gust. I was not making a formal visibility measurement, and I did not inspect every part of the sky. A later description such as “clear conditions” should be understood as my general impression of the part of the scene I could see.\n\nI heard activity from the equipment area and a low distant background noise. Nothing stood out as clearly connected to the light. I did not identify an engine sound, but I was not using headphones or a directional microphone. I cannot infer from my hearing that an acoustic sensor should have recorded nothing. I had no unusual physical symptoms during the interval. I did not see a flash at ground level or any movement at the place where the collection team later described a surface mark.\n\nAfter the session I heard Observer A use the word triangle. That differed from what I had seen, and I kept “oval” in my written account. I do not know whether the difference came from position, brightness, attention, a change over time, or our having looked at different sources. I would like the report to retain both descriptions instead of choosing the more detailed one. A useful comparison would include the two viewpoints, the timing limits and the original recordings, without assuming in advance that both accounts must refer to one object.\n\n## Sketch instruction\n\nThe associated drawing should show an unresolved pale oval, the foreground branch and the ridge gap. Its caption should read “overall appearance from South; internal points unresolved.” It should not use a solid vehicle silhouette or suggest an independently measured ellipse. See [illustration specifications](image-briefs.md).\n",
      "line": 1,
      "citation": {
        "document": {
          "documentId": "meridian-assessment-input-entities-v1",
          "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:research-entities:0.2.0",
          "sha256": "fa88c7cfdc2577e97f2b75e06417e3121acdffabe34db0de47aa7d35f1da0fec"
        },
        "editionId": "account-b",
        "artifact": {
          "sourceRef": "source:r2-account-b",
          "digest": {
            "algorithm": "sha256",
            "value": "5d30dbfd7c869e02a4107d946ede44b81478f44a0fd2ae01d8c65868c73d4cef"
          }
        },
        "locator": {
          "kind": "page",
          "page": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "follow-up",
      "title": "Observer A · follow-up",
      "file": "inputs/account-a-follow-up.md",
      "base": "reader",
      "editionId": "account-a-follow-up",
      "page": 1,
      "note": "Clarifies apparent motion and prior exposure to the plotted channels.",
      "originalFile": "sources/account-a-follow-up.md",
      "sourceRef": "source:r2-account-a-follow-up",
      "sha256": "a511d08bac441b967868257170c1c9df383894d94457d8015cef98420ee7c889",
      "byteLength": 2082,
      "excerpt": "# Observer A · Follow-up clarification\n\nFictional source. Recorded 16 August 2026 after the initial report was issued. This is a second account from Observer A, not an additional witness. It was not sworn.\n\n<a id=\"account\"></a>\n## Account\n\nI have now read the first report and seen the three plotted channels. I want to clarify what I meant by “moved upward” in my first account. I meant that the light's apparent position changed relative to the ridge. I did not measure its distance, and I did not calculate a physical speed. The plotted optical angle is useful context, but I cannot independently confirm that every plotted sample corresponds to the light I was watching.\n\nThe graph also made me more aware of how uncertain my timing is. My original estimate of about a minute was a recollection. It was not obtained by matching the beginning and end of the curve. If I give a more precise time after looking at that graph, that would be a later inference influenced by the recording, not an improvement in the precision of my original observation. Please retain the date and wording of the first account alongside this clarification.\n\nI still remember the triangular arrangement, with darkness between the points. I do not remember a connecting surface. I am less comfortable with drawings that turn the arrangement into the outline of a solid triangular object. The sketch in my first account should be read as a map of remembered lights. B's different description does not cause me to withdraw mine, but I do not know enough to explain the difference or to establish that we saw the same thing.\n\nI also want to separate the later collection work from what I observed. I did not see the surface mark form, and I cannot link it to the light. A material sample may be useful as a record of the site, especially with a nearby control, but my statement provides no basis for calling that material unusual. Further work should start with the actual source files, their timing and the collection documentation rather than treating the grouping of these records as a conclusion.\n",
      "line": 1,
      "citation": {
        "document": {
          "documentId": "meridian-assessment-input-entities-v1",
          "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:research-entities:0.2.0",
          "sha256": "fa88c7cfdc2577e97f2b75e06417e3121acdffabe34db0de47aa7d35f1da0fec"
        },
        "editionId": "account-a-follow-up",
        "artifact": {
          "sourceRef": "source:r2-account-a-follow-up",
          "digest": {
            "algorithm": "sha256",
            "value": "a511d08bac441b967868257170c1c9df383894d94457d8015cef98420ee7c889"
          }
        },
        "locator": {
          "kind": "page",
          "page": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "site",
      "title": "Local site plan",
      "file": "inputs/site-plan.svg",
      "base": "reader",
      "editionId": null,
      "page": null,
      "note": "Authored station positions; no target range or reconstructed path.",
      "originalFile": "sources/site-plan.svg",
      "sourceRef": "source:r2-site-plan",
      "sha256": "fd4b5b5cab3b8d84e6cfebd72d02bce59bef2194b320d7b87c2ab8f054210b5b",
      "byteLength": 2445,
      "excerpt": null,
      "line": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "inventory",
      "title": "Recording specifications",
      "file": "inputs/asset-specifications.json",
      "base": "reader",
      "editionId": null,
      "page": null,
      "note": "Specifications describe intended products, not new observations.",
      "originalFile": "sources/asset-specifications.json",
      "sourceRef": "source:r2-asset-specifications",
      "sha256": "6143000e440d25e5c986ce771aebdd64b10e39f6d8498b4baeab64cde92dc09c",
      "byteLength": 43652,
      "excerpt": null,
      "line": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "optical",
      "title": "Original optical readings",
      "file": "inputs/optical.csv",
      "base": "original",
      "editionId": null,
      "page": null,
      "note": "Elevation angle does not determine distance or physical speed.",
      "originalFile": "optical.csv",
      "sourceRef": "source:review-original-optical",
      "sha256": "08ae25c833684504eb82942df5b7367dbfacc6be31d71ae1cc584e6fffeb4175",
      "byteLength": 861,
      "excerpt": null,
      "line": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "radio",
      "title": "Original radio readings",
      "file": "inputs/radio.csv",
      "base": "original",
      "editionId": null,
      "page": null,
      "note": "Power alone does not identify an emitter or connect it to a light.",
      "originalFile": "radio.csv",
      "sourceRef": "source:review-original-radio",
      "sha256": "fe18aff93123886c6c1b6f1117f76daf8ab074aa30e93c1bccbe1988b8e854ee",
      "byteLength": 879,
      "excerpt": null,
      "line": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "temperature",
      "title": "Original ambient readings",
      "file": "inputs/temperature.csv",
      "base": "original",
      "editionId": null,
      "page": null,
      "note": "A station measurement, not the temperature of the observed light.",
      "originalFile": "temperature.csv",
      "sourceRef": "source:review-original-temperature",
      "sha256": "4a9c6622088b89d469d190b2a3dc4169af6f8d3a39374b08ef143bfeff370478",
      "byteLength": 865,
      "excerpt": null,
      "line": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "generator",
      "title": "Original source generator",
      "file": "inputs/fixture.mjs",
      "base": "original",
      "editionId": null,
      "page": null,
      "note": "Known shared simulation limits what curve resemblance can establish.",
      "originalFile": "fixture.mjs",
      "sourceRef": "source:review-original-generator",
      "sha256": "e641ab9ccca73c66eff50b858b59c60f1801f8a351a17f32865f4d829cc2d7aa",
      "byteLength": 26339,
      "excerpt": null,
      "line": 1
    }
  ],
  "inputChanges": {
    "added": [
      "report-b",
      "follow-up",
      "inventory"
    ],
    "removed": [
      "report-a"
    ],
    "retained": [
      "account-a",
      "account-b",
      "optical",
      "radio",
      "temperature",
      "generator"
    ]
  },
  "method": {
    "id": "source-comparison",
    "version": "1",
    "description": "# Meridian source-comparison review / version 1\n\nFictional qualitative review of a bounded source set. No statistical inference, source authentication or independent scientific review is performed.\n\n1. Preserve each report edition, account and scalar file by its exact digest.\n2. Ask whether the selected sources establish a common physical source. Keep timing, geometry, emitter identity and observer recollection separate.\n3. Read each complete review-note section as an attributed rationale. Keep the initial claim, the same team's revision and the other reviewer's alternative distinct. Only the revised shared-source claim supersedes the initial one; the independent explanation is not a revision or the winner.\n4. Compare the exact input sets. Report A is replaced by report B as an input to the revised review; the original remains available. Observer A's follow-up and recording specifications are added. The first accounts, scalar files and their generator remain byte-identical.\n5. Retain an inconclusive outcome. Neither a hypothesis nor a resolved reference establishes physical association. Do not create a probability or overall scientific grade.\n\nThe short labels, input contribution notes, limits and follow-up prompts in catalog.json are authored reading aids. They do not add weighting or a normative supporting/challenging relation to the claim contract. Full review rationales are taken verbatim from reader-r2/sources/reviews.md, with exact line ranges in the application projection. Canonical provenance retains the source digest; no unsupported line locator is invented in the standard. Source-edition inputs use exact edition/page citations.\n\nThese dated reviews describe the sourcebook at its recorded stage. Later instrument captures, image arrays and material studies elsewhere in the showcase are not silently added as inputs. The earlier short-example history remains unchanged; this expanded review history is separately identified and does not supersede across snapshots.\n"
  },
  "sources": {
    "catalog.json": {
      "sha256": "54d29ba2aa0396b3a55aa30ec7c4567491ba1ff3fc3785c0bf321d9c5a4c998c",
      "byteLength": 5989
    },
    "method.md": {
      "sha256": "810c73fee1a4186fb7e554a1db1de7e8849ffcb830047763ef0bbbfe37edfa22",
      "byteLength": 2003
    },
    "inputs/report-a.md": {
      "sha256": "461eb15b81e16b4950b6a8b06b5852db10cc753a66794d42e2c13804c013ff04",
      "byteLength": 5881
    },
    "inputs/report-b.md": {
      "sha256": "be42555e86eb0f4419ade177687960448adb6aa5523117e61580230d21ce7eb1",
      "byteLength": 7217
    },
    "inputs/account-a.md": {
      "sha256": "19fdf581a00c9a634a042f7d52ef6784c240e0d6146f7ab420505be34cb80d48",
      "byteLength": 4590
    },
    "inputs/account-b.md": {
      "sha256": "5d30dbfd7c869e02a4107d946ede44b81478f44a0fd2ae01d8c65868c73d4cef",
      "byteLength": 4617
    },
    "inputs/account-a-follow-up.md": {
      "sha256": "a511d08bac441b967868257170c1c9df383894d94457d8015cef98420ee7c889",
      "byteLength": 2082
    },
    "inputs/site-plan.svg": {
      "sha256": "fd4b5b5cab3b8d84e6cfebd72d02bce59bef2194b320d7b87c2ab8f054210b5b",
      "byteLength": 2445
    },
    "inputs/asset-specifications.json": {
      "sha256": "6143000e440d25e5c986ce771aebdd64b10e39f6d8498b4baeab64cde92dc09c",
      "byteLength": 43652
    },
    "inputs/optical.csv": {
      "sha256": "08ae25c833684504eb82942df5b7367dbfacc6be31d71ae1cc584e6fffeb4175",
      "byteLength": 861
    },
    "inputs/radio.csv": {
      "sha256": "fe18aff93123886c6c1b6f1117f76daf8ab074aa30e93c1bccbe1988b8e854ee",
      "byteLength": 879
    },
    "inputs/temperature.csv": {
      "sha256": "4a9c6622088b89d469d190b2a3dc4169af6f8d3a39374b08ef143bfeff370478",
      "byteLength": 865
    },
    "inputs/fixture.mjs": {
      "sha256": "e641ab9ccca73c66eff50b858b59c60f1801f8a351a17f32865f4d829cc2d7aa",
      "byteLength": 26339
    },
    "inputs/reviews.md": {
      "sha256": "24a285742351a0063cbbf1c03d64f8bfc911c6abe4524c0b2d00c7499fefe622",
      "byteLength": 4804
    }
  }
}
