{
  "kind": "case_claim_history",
  "schemaVersion": "0.1.0",
  "id": "meridian-material-field-review-v1",
  "caseRefs": [
    {
      "documentId": "meridian-material-field-review-case-v1",
      "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:case-record:0.1.0",
      "sha256": "e83c46d1982518bd7be9e1de3b8945c409e50f5563506457857b82184b66ffda"
    }
  ],
  "claims": [
    {
      "id": "material-field-relation",
      "kind": "assessment",
      "recordedAt": "2026-08-18T12:30:00Z",
      "topic": "material_corroboration",
      "subject": {
        "kind": "case_relation",
        "from": {
          "case": {
            "documentId": "meridian-material-field-review-case-v1",
            "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:case-record:0.1.0",
            "sha256": "e83c46d1982518bd7be9e1de3b8945c409e50f5563506457857b82184b66ffda"
          },
          "observationId": "meridian-reviewed-specimens-v1"
        },
        "to": {
          "case": {
            "documentId": "meridian-material-field-review-case-v1",
            "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:case-record:0.1.0",
            "sha256": "e83c46d1982518bd7be9e1de3b8945c409e50f5563506457857b82184b66ffda"
          },
          "observationId": "meridian-014"
        },
        "relation": "corroborates"
      },
      "status": "assessed",
      "outcome": "inconclusive",
      "evaluatedBy": "Meridian material review team (fictional)",
      "evaluatedAt": "2026-08-18T12:30:00Z",
      "methodVersion": "1",
      "rationale": "A shared case provides context. It does not establish a common cause.\n\nThe case groups the retained field observation with the expanded specimen record. The collection sheet places the soil within the fictional investigation; the laboratory report explicitly supplies no mechanism connecting it to the recorded light. The direction under review is material record toward field observation.\n\nA handling history and attributed analytical results make the specimen record more inspectable. They do not establish when the surface feature formed or whether it arose from the same event. No same-object link, reverse corroboration or causal relationship is inferred.\n\nLimits: The directed corroboration question remains inconclusive. Case membership is organizational and neither observation is merged or relabeled.\n\nNext: Define a testable association criterion and obtain independent temporal, spatial and physical observations that could support or challenge it.",
      "methodRef": {
        "case": {
          "documentId": "meridian-material-field-review-case-v1",
          "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:case-record:0.1.0",
          "sha256": "e83c46d1982518bd7be9e1de3b8945c409e50f5563506457857b82184b66ffda"
        },
        "observationId": "meridian-reviewed-specimens-v1",
        "methodId": "precise-subject-review"
      },
      "inputRefs": [],
      "caseInputRefs": [
        {
          "kind": "case_basis",
          "document": {
            "documentId": "meridian-material-field-review-case-v1",
            "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:case-record:0.1.0",
            "sha256": "e83c46d1982518bd7be9e1de3b8945c409e50f5563506457857b82184b66ffda"
          },
          "target": {
            "kind": "membership",
            "id": "material-record"
          }
        }
      ],
      "observationInputRefs": [
        {
          "case": {
            "documentId": "meridian-material-field-review-case-v1",
            "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:case-record:0.1.0",
            "sha256": "e83c46d1982518bd7be9e1de3b8945c409e50f5563506457857b82184b66ffda"
          },
          "observationId": "meridian-reviewed-specimens-v1",
          "ref": "source:specimen-collection-sheet"
        },
        {
          "case": {
            "documentId": "meridian-material-field-review-case-v1",
            "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:case-record:0.1.0",
            "sha256": "e83c46d1982518bd7be9e1de3b8945c409e50f5563506457857b82184b66ffda"
          },
          "observationId": "meridian-reviewed-specimens-v1",
          "ref": "source:specimen-laboratory-report"
        },
        {
          "case": {
            "documentId": "meridian-material-field-review-case-v1",
            "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:case-record:0.1.0",
            "sha256": "e83c46d1982518bd7be9e1de3b8945c409e50f5563506457857b82184b66ffda"
          },
          "observationId": "meridian-014",
          "ref": "source:station-log"
        },
        {
          "case": {
            "documentId": "meridian-material-field-review-case-v1",
            "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:case-record:0.1.0",
            "sha256": "e83c46d1982518bd7be9e1de3b8945c409e50f5563506457857b82184b66ffda"
          },
          "observationId": "meridian-reviewed-specimens-v1",
          "ref": "source:subject-review-reviews.json"
        },
        {
          "case": {
            "documentId": "meridian-material-field-review-case-v1",
            "schemaId": "urn:disclosureos:experimental:case-record:0.1.0",
            "sha256": "e83c46d1982518bd7be9e1de3b8945c409e50f5563506457857b82184b66ffda"
          },
          "observationId": "meridian-reviewed-specimens-v1",
          "ref": "source:subject-review-method.md"
        }
      ]
    }
  ]
}
