{
  "fictional": true,
  "recordedAt": "2026-10-13T12:00:00Z",
  "evaluatedBy": "Meridian vocabulary review team (fictional)",
  "scope": "Selected research questions about the sourcebook and original scalar captures. Catalog membership is not a finding. Other entries have no assessment in this packet.",
  "reviews": [
    {
      "id": "angular-motion",
      "kind": "observable",
      "entryId": "abrupt_motion",
      "title": "An apparent rise is not an acceleration measurement",
      "inputs": [
        "report-b",
        "account-a",
        "follow-up",
        "optical"
      ],
      "rationale": "Observer A describes an apparent rise relative to the ridge. The follow-up distinguishes that impression from a measurement of physical motion. The retained optical CSV contains an elevation angle, with no supplied distance to the light. These sources do not determine a three-dimensional trajectory or physical acceleration.\n\nThe physical-acceleration question has an inconclusive outcome. This does not decide whether any apparent motion was reported. Neither a positive finding nor an absence of unusual acceleration follows from this source set. Later instrument demonstrations are separately identified captures and are not substituted for missing field measurements.",
      "limits": "Range, camera pointing and independently characterized timing are missing for this comparison.",
      "followUp": "Obtain a calibrated line of sight, independent range information and timing uncertainties; compare a declared trajectory model against background and alternative motion models.",
      "question": "Do these sources establish physical acceleration?"
    },
    {
      "id": "sensor-visibility",
      "kind": "observable",
      "entryId": "sensor_detection_discrepancy",
      "title": "Different views need comparable observations",
      "inputs": [
        "report-b",
        "account-a",
        "account-b",
        "site",
        "radio"
      ],
      "rationale": "Observer A reports separated lights while Observer B describes a soft patch through an obstruction. These are different accounts of viewing conditions, not a documented multi-sensor loss of track. The original scalar radio channel supplies a power value without identifying the emitter.\n\nThis source set does not establish a detection discrepancy for the same object under comparable sensor conditions. It also does not demonstrate that every relevant sensor could have detected it. The assessment remains inconclusive until source identity, coverage, sensitivity and detection thresholds are specified.",
      "limits": "There is no matched object track across modalities, measured sensitivity threshold or verified occlusion model.",
      "followUp": "Document pointing, obstruction and sensitivity for each capture; test whether the same source should have been detectable under those conditions.",
      "question": "Do comparable sensors show a detection discrepancy for the same source?"
    },
    {
      "id": "optical-explanation",
      "kind": "origin",
      "entryId": "1.1.1.1.1",
      "title": "Viewing conditions or an optical effect",
      "inputs": [
        "report-b",
        "account-a",
        "account-b",
        "site"
      ],
      "rationale": "Different stations and a partly obstructed view make an optical or viewing-condition explanation worth testing. The accounts describe apparent shapes without resolving a shared surface. That is compatible with several viewing effects, but compatibility is not an identification.\n\nNo lens model, exposure sequence or reconstructed line of sight is supplied in this dated packet. The report therefore does not identify a reflection, mirage or other specific effect. A source that persisted across controlled changes of viewpoint would place a different constraint on this explanation.",
      "limits": "The record does not reproduce a specific optical effect or establish the geometry needed to test one.",
      "followUp": "Repeat observations from documented positions with controlled optics and known lights; compare predicted image changes with independently timed native captures.",
      "question": "Do viewing conditions or an optical effect explain the reported light?"
    },
    {
      "id": "celestial-explanation",
      "kind": "origin",
      "entryId": "1.1.1.1.2",
      "title": "A celestial or orbiting source",
      "inputs": [
        "report-b",
        "account-a",
        "follow-up",
        "site",
        "optical"
      ],
      "rationale": "A distant light is a possible comparison class in the origin framework. Apparent motion relative to a ridge is insufficient to determine its distance, and Observer A’s later clarification does not provide a physical speed. A celestial or orbiting explanation remains a question, not a catalog match.\n\nThe fictional local site diagram has no geodetic registration, and the original angular channel is not a complete astrometric solution. No ephemeris match has been run. Later sky demonstrations do not supply the missing registration for these retained sources.",
      "limits": "Exact observing location, pointing and source-specific timing are insufficient for an ephemeris comparison.",
      "followUp": "Supply geodetic location, calibrated pointing and timing uncertainty, then retain the catalog version and residuals from a reproducible sky/ephemeris comparison.",
      "question": "Does a celestial or orbiting source explain the reported light?"
    },
    {
      "id": "human-explanation",
      "kind": "origin",
      "entryId": "1.1.1.2.4",
      "title": "A conventional human-operated source",
      "inputs": [
        "report-b",
        "account-a",
        "account-b",
        "radio",
        "generator"
      ],
      "rationale": "Conventional aircraft, drones or lights can be considered without presuming a novel origin. The supplied accounts do not identify a vehicle. The original scalar radio file does not identify an emitter or establish a relationship to the visible light; its shared synthetic generator with the optical curve makes resemblance an unsuitable independent test.\n\nNo flight-log, vehicle-registration or source-resolved radio match is supplied. Nor does the absence of such a match in this packet exclude a conventional source. The private/commercial framework node is used as a defined example question, not an attribution to a person or organization.",
      "limits": "No independently matched vehicle, flight path or emitter is available in this review’s source set.",
      "followUp": "Compare documented pointing and time bounds with appropriate flight/source records, state their coverage limits and retain mismatches as well as candidate matches.",
      "question": "Does a conventional human-operated source explain the reported light?"
    }
  ]
}
